Police may say they just want your side of the story, that you are not a suspect, or that cooperating will go a long way. In this episode of Reasonable Doubt, host Michelle Rotella talks with Christian Lueders, founder of Guardian Law Group and a former prosecutor, about what those lines are for, and how to respond.
Christian’s advice starts with a simple distinction: you can be respectful and obedient to police without helping them investigate you. If officers want a statement about a crime, the clear response is that you want to talk to an attorney before you answer questions. Then actually stop talking.
Is Giving Police Your Side Of The Story Ever A Good Idea?
You can be respectful and obedient to police without helping them investigate you. When an officer says they just want your side of the story, that can sound reasonable. Especially if you have not done anything wrong, the natural reaction is to explain what happened. Their job in that moment, though, is to investigate a potential crime and gather evidence. Everything you tell them becomes part of that investigation and informs their decisions going forward.
Arizona officers go through extensive academy and field training. At no point in that training, Christian says, does an officer take a class called how to be fair to a criminal suspect. They may be friendly. They may be completely professional. They are not your friend in that situation, and they are not there to help you build a defense against potential charges.
The bigger problem is that you do not know what they already know. You do not know what another witness has already told them, or what video, photographs, or other evidence they already have. Answering questions without that full picture is how you walk into a trap.
What Should You Say If Police Want To Question You About A Crime?
Be polite. Be respectful. If they give you a lawful command, follow it. But if the police want words from your mouth about something involving a criminal act, that is the time to say you would like to talk to an attorney. Those are the words that matter. If you are the target of an investigation, they cannot question you anymore after you say them.
Say it emphatically: you want to talk to an attorney before you answer any questions. You can always decide later to change your mind and provide information. You cannot take back something you have already said to a cop.
How Much Reassurance Should You Take If An Officer Says You Are Not A Suspect?
Almost none. Officers are trained to say things like “you’re not a suspect” and “you’re not under arrest.” That may be true in that moment. They are still talking to you for a reason. The information you give them can be used later, just as the Miranda warnings say.
If you are told you are not under arrest, a useful next question is whether you are free to go. If the officer says yes, be polite, be respectful, and go.
Does Asking For An Attorney Make You Look Guilty?
No. Officers are used to this. You do not have to stand there and answer questions just because an officer would like you to. This is not about being anti-police. Their job is to investigate and gather evidence, even if that means you are the suspect. Your job in that moment is to make sure you are not helping them build a potential case against you later.
Why Can Talking Still Create Problems For Someone Who Is Innocent?
Two common assumptions are that if you did nothing wrong you have nothing to worry about, and that if a police officer asks questions you have to answer. In almost any situation, when an officer is asking about a criminal act and how you are involved in it, you are under no obligation to answer.
A lawful stop is different. If an officer had a lawful reason to pull you over and asks for your ID, you have to provide it. In most circumstances, you also have to provide identifying information when they ask for it. That is not the same thing as explaining your involvement in a crime.
If you do open your mouth, do not lie. In certain situations, it is a crime to lie to an officer. It is also best not to start that conversation in the first place. You do not have to explain why you are not answering questions.
You can be completely innocent and still say something that creates a problem. People get nervous. They get a time, a date, or a name wrong. That can look like an inconsistency, or even like dishonesty, especially if the police already know the answer and are asking to see whether your account matches the evidence they have. Choosing not to answer questions is not something only guilty people do. You have the right to remain silent for a reason. Be respectful, be polite, and use it.
Are The Police Allowed To Lie During An Investigation?
Yes. Officers can use deception. They can tell you something that is not true during an investigation to try to get the information they want. Christian calls this one of their best tools in that setting. They may say they already know what happened, that a witness has already told them everything, or that a friend has already given you up. That may or may not be true. You have no way of knowing.
The danger is the urge to correct them, or to make sure they hear your side. That is what they want: to get you talking. This does not mean the officer is doing something illegal. You do not need to figure out whether they are bluffing, and you do not have to argue. Be respectful and say you are not answering any questions without your attorney.
If You Cooperate, Will An Officer Be Able To Help Your Case?
An officer can tell the prosecutor that you cooperated. The officer is not the prosecutor, and is not in control of what charges ultimately get filed or what happens with your case. Very often, charging decisions depend very little on how much a person cooperated at the scene.
People get themselves into trouble when they start answering questions and admitting to things because they think they are earning credit, and there may be no way the prosecutor or the judge is going to consider that later. If cooperation really could benefit you, that is a conversation to have with an attorney involved. That is when an empty offer can turn into something that might actually mean something. An attorney can ask what they are offering in return, and get it in writing.
If an officer says, “just be honest with me and we can work this out,” in most cases they do not have the authority to negotiate that. Easing the damage of criminal charges is usually something that takes a prosecutor, and a defense attorney, getting involved.
Can You Stop Answering Questions After You Have Already Started Talking?
Yes. It is never too late to stop talking. It does not matter if you have already answered five questions. You do not have to answer the sixth.
You can say you do not want to answer any more questions, that you want to speak with an attorney, and ask whether you are free to go or whether you are under arrest. The most important part is to actually stop talking. Do not say you think you want an attorney. Be emphatic, and leave no room for interpretation: you want an attorney, and you want to talk to them now, before you answer any more questions. Do not try to clear something up. Do not fill the silence. Stay polite, ask for an attorney, and stop talking.
Remember This
- You can be polite and follow a lawful command without helping an investigation.
- If police want words from you about a criminal act, say you would like to talk to an attorney. Those are the words that stop questioning if you are the target of the investigation.
- You can later decide to give a statement. You cannot take back something you have already said to a cop.
- If an officer says you are not a suspect, take almost no reassurance from that. They are still talking to you for a reason.
- It is never too late to stop talking, even if you have already answered some questions. Be emphatic, ask for an attorney, and then actually stop talking. Do not fill the silence.
Under investigation or already charged? See how we handle criminal defense and felony charges, or hear more on the Reasonable Doubt podcast page.
Talk To A Former Prosecutor About Your Case.
Former Prosecutor. Fighting for You Now.